I own Custom Booklet Printing in Phoenix. These are the questions I get every week, answered the way I answer them on the phone.
When should someone pick saddle stitch and when perfect bound?
It always comes down to three things. The first one is price point. Saddle stitching is cheaper than perfect binding, typically. The reason why is the equipment. The average booklet maker can run in between 2,000 to 4,000 books an hour on saddle stitch, and that applies to self cover and plus cover books.
When you run a perfect bind machine, you have to let the glue kind of settle. Typically you're only able to bind maybe 400 to 1,000 books per hour, and it depends on how thick they are and how much glue is going down. So that's why perfect bind is slower and it takes more time to actually produce the product. Saddle stitching is cheaper and it's faster.
So when is it that a customer must go perfect bind? Typically, anything more than a 68-page book. Once you start to go over that, meaning 72 or anything above 68, that's when you would want to consider going perfect bound. It's primarily just page count. The books tend to get really thick in the spine, and the staples have a very hard time punching through all of those sheets of paper. They definitely have a hard time punching through if you've also got it on a plus cover, where the cover is thicker than the guts.
Which one holds up better?
In my opinion, saddle stitch is a much better way for book binding to get done. The reason I say that is after a certain amount of times on perfect bind, the glue breaks down. You open and close a perfect bind book so much that it gets weaker and weaker every time, to the point that eventually the pages will fall out of the glue. With saddle stitching you don't have that. There's no glue. There's staples that are literally holding the pages together.
How do you count the pages in a book?
A lot of times people don't know how to count pages. They also think that because a page is blank and there's no printing there, you don't get to count it as a page. That is incorrect.
When the book is closed and sitting right in front of you, the front cover is page 1. Open the front cover and now you're looking at the inside of the front cover. That is page 2. Then you're looking at the guts of the book. That is page 3. And it goes so on and so forth. This applies to plus cover and self cover.
Saddle stitch books always have to be divisible by 4. One 11 x 17 folded is 4 pages. That's not technically a book. That's kind of like a brochure. But a second 11 x 17, folded and placed inside of the first one, now makes it an 8-pager.
So if someone tells me they have a 22-page saddle stitch book, I immediately know that is wrong. It's either a 20-pager or a 24-pager. Most of the time when I hear 22, it really is a 24. It typically never goes down, it always goes up. Same thing for a 38-pager. It's either a 36 or, more than likely, a 40.
Most of the time when they add the blank pages, they add them to the inside front cover and inside back cover. Or they might just make the very last gut page in the book blank. There is absolutely nothing on it, but it still counts as a page.
How many pages can a perfect bound book be?
Our website stops at 116 pages on perfect bind. That doesn't mean I'm limited on my manufacturing. It stopped at 116 just because I didn't want to quote anything more than that on the website. I believe we can go all the way up to 300 pages. I think the largest we've done is a 320. But anything like 120 pages on up, the customer needs to call for a quote. Up to 116 pages you can price perfect bound book printing on our site by page count and quantity.
Those bigger jobs typically end up being in between 10 and 20,000 dollars, and when we're doing things like that I like to talk to the customer, find out more about the job and see examples of it.
Any book job over the $20,000 mark, I would typically tell the customer they probably should not buy it from an out-of-state printer. They should be printing it locally and doing press checks on it. If a mistake doesn't get caught and the job ships, which is typically pallets going from one state to the next, you're now talking $2,000 in shipping. It could get very costly to ship the job back to the printer, have them fix it, and then ship it back for the third time.
What do people get wrong with their files?
Number one, we always ask for a PDF. If a customer sends it a different way, you have to be very careful. Let's say they've got different styles of fonts in the piece, and those were downloaded and installed into their Photoshop or Illustrator, and we do not have those fonts installed. I open the file and it might use a default font, and I didn't even know that it changed.
Let's say that font was only used in a few key positions. I send the customer a PDF proof, they don't catch it, they approve it, and we print it like that. It could go south pretty quick. That's why PDFs are definitely the best way to go. Before sending files to the printer, businesses should focus on preparing professional print materials with consistent typography, accurate colours, and layouts that match their brand guidelines.
Another thing is we do not want reader spreads. Reader spreads is when you're clicking through like you're reading a book on a computer screen. We want printer spreads, so when it gets manufactured into a book everything is laid out correctly.
Sometimes on saddle stitch books, on 64 or 68 pagers, customers do not account for creep. Creep is when the center spread of the book sticks out of the face of the book a little bit more than the covers. The paper at the spine just naturally pushes the center spread out. A lot of printers with booklet makers do a final trim on the head, foot and face, so when the book is closed all the pages match perfectly.
If the file wasn't designed with creep being considered, there might be some text or some picture getting cut off in the center spread. You don't have that issue with perfect bind, because the pages don't fold over each other. This is not common knowledge to the general public. It's actually one of the ways you can tell a good designer from a bad designer.
Other things are a little more common. Not adding a bleed. You have to have a bleed, especially if you've got images. 1/8 of an inch is all we need at our shop. I can't speak for other shops. For larger projects, managing and organizing PDF files before submission can make it easier to combine pages, remove duplicates, and ensure the final document is ready for review.
I've also seen customers accidentally double up a page number. It'll go page 12, you flip the page, and it goes 12 again. That causes the rest of the page numbers through the rest of the book to be completely off. One of the tells is you're printing a 68-pager but the numbers only go to 67.
And you want to be at least at 300 DPI. 400 or 500 DPI is overkill. The colors end up blending together and they look a little bit muddy. Anything under 200, you can start to see things get a little bit blurry. At 150 or 125 it's very noticeable, and it just doesn't look like a professional job.
Why are you cheaper on perfect bound than other online printers?
There's a couple reasons. Number one, when we print the job on our J Press, it is actually collating the book as we're printing it. That is a huge savings. Typical offset is not able to do that. They have to print all of the press sheet sigs, sometimes do a small trim, run it through a folder, and after they're done folding it they have to collate it. Then they're able to perfect bind it.
All those steps I get to skip. I get to go straight from press directly over to perfect bind, which is the gluing. That saves a lot of time and money depending on the page count and the quantity. Another reason is most of our equipment is paid off. We don't have payments on it.
What should someone ordering their first book know?
If the customer has done their research, they've called the printer from out of state, they feel comfortable with that printer, they've seen the samples, they know they can get hard copies from that printer, and the job is under $5,000, I think it's safe to say they can order the job from an online printer. They just need to do their due diligence and not assume anything.
They need to have a little bit of knowledge about books. How to order them, what paper stocks there are, what options they might have, what proofing they can do. Calling the print shop and asking those questions is the number one step, and then feeling comfortable with the guy.
So call the printer. Ask them about quality. Ask them about their equipment. Ask how the proofing works and what types of papers they have. Request some samples, or maybe get a video showing samples. Maybe go over some coating options too.
If the printer's got good customer service, is very knowledgeable, answers all the questions to a T, and gets back with them pretty promptly, then I would feel comfortable sending a job out of state, especially for a first-time customer.
However, if they've never done it before, they're not familiar, and they don't do their own research, they should probably be keeping it in state, so they get to see how it works and learn the process.
Either way, they need to be getting hard copy proofs. The hard copy proofs are everything. The chances of something going wrong go up quite a bit if a customer does not get them. Whether you're printing a booklet, catalogue, or business brochure, maintaining a consistent brand identity across physical and digital materials helps create a more professional impression
Another thing they can do at home is print out a little miniature book on their desktop printer, cut it all out, make those little pages into a book, staple it, and review everything that way.
Guys like me specialize, and we have certain pieces of equipment that give us an advantage, and that allows us to pass those savings on to the customer. That's why we're a little bit cheaper.
A lot of times customers make the mistake of assuming. In printing, and I would even say in manufacturing, you cannot assume anything. And if it's a local printer, ask if you can set up a press check so you can be there and look at everything while they are printing your job.
Read More Blogs On: